Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Olympia, Nov. 29th, Ways & Means Commitee

My name is Ned Hammar. I am a family doctor working at a community clinic in Okanogan. I drove six and a half hours to be here.

I am here today on behalf of those who have no voice.

I am here today to speak for my 38-year-old patient with pelvic cramping. She had light spotting of blood and found that her IUD was coming out. We tried to get another IUD to replace it but could not because she had no insurance. We tried to offer her condoms but she declined them because her husband beats her up if she uses them. We tried to offer help but she said she couldn’t leave the situation because of her children.

This woman faces an unplanned child born into an abusive relationship in a family already struggling to get by, because she can not afford safe and effective contraception.

I am here to speak for my 47-year-old patient who just wants to get back to working as a short-order cook, but can’t because the voices in his head tell him to kill himself. He’s been into our clinic five times in the last year in suicidal crisis. Each of those times we’ve tried to get him admitted to emergency psychiatric care but each time this has been denied because he can’t pay. He can’t afford a medicine that keeps the voices at bay and costs $17 a month.

I am waiting for the phone call to tell me that he is dead, because we couldn’t help him find $17 a month.

I am here today to speak for my 9-month-old patient. This little girl was born to a mom who had just one prenatal visit. She appeared normal at birth but at her 1-week check-up she stopped breathing and turned blue. In the hospital she started seizing, and she was sent by air to Spokane. There she had a massive stroke and lost 90% of the temporal lobes of her brain. Somehow she lived. But she will never walk. She will never talk. She will never play patty-cake, or read a book, or sing a song.

This girl had a herpes infection that reached her brain, which could have been prevented if her mom had received adequate prenatal care.

I am here to tell you that our system is failing, and it is failing those who have very little left to lose. If these budget cuts go through, you are asking them to let go of one final thing. It may seem like a small thing but in my experience as a family doctor it seems to be the only thing some folks have left.

You are asking them to let go of hope.

I have heard that one of the accusations leveled against the Occupy movement is that they don’t have an “ask.” So I’ve thought very carefully about what my “ask” is, if I’m going to come here and take up your time.

My “ask” is very simple. My “ask” is that you tax the wealthiest individuals and corporations in order to pay for basic healthcare and education for all.

You might say, “Well, that failed. I-1098 last fall put that exact choice to the people and it was voted down.” To which I would point out that for 6 of the 7 months that polls were conducted, I-1098 was supported, initially by a margin of 66% for to 27% against. Only an aggressive and highly-funded campaign which played to baseless fears was able to convince people to vote against their own best interest.

More to the point, I would remind you that Washington State has the most regressive tax structure in the nation. The poorest fifth pay 17% of their income in taxes, while the richest 1% pay only 2.6% percent. From 1979 until now, the income percentage of almost everyone has dropped, but the richest fifth have increased their share 6 points from 43 to 49%—and the wealth disparity is far greater.

This is an outrage. There are people dying on our streets and in our clinics, in my clinic, every day, while the richest of the rich linger over the choice between a new yacht and a private airplane. This is an outrage.
The argument against raising taxes on the wealthy is that we will no longer attract the best and the brightest minds to our State to be the innovators and doers of tomorrow. I ask you, what about the minds we have here? Are we willing to write off 80% of our population as worthless? Are we willing to pin our hopes on the richest 1-2% of individuals and corporations, hoping that somehow they will smile on the rest of us? If we are, then the last 30 years should give us some idea of what to expect. Do we have better schools? Better clinic? Better health? Safer neighborhoods? Cleaner air? Better transportation? A secure economic future?

Study after study shows that the health of a community can be best predicted by one single measure: a lower income gap between rich and poor. Over the past 30 years our income gap has widened, and our schools, neighborhoods, clinics, our health, our future, our hope have suffered as a result.

I can’t pretend that reversing this trend will be easy. The defeat of I-1098, a measure which would have directly benefitted 98% of our people while asking a nominal tithe of the remaining 2%, illustrates the power of the wealthiest individuals and corporations.

Nonetheless I ask you to try. John Burbank and the Economic Opportunity Institute offer some specific measures which would close corporate tax loopholes and protect social services, while both protecting the environment and stimulating economic growth. I ask you to look at these and other measures which more equally share the responsibility for our current crisis. We the people need you to try. Our future, which is to say the future of Washington itself, depends upon it.

I ask you to give us hope. Not the gaunt, stretched, thin hope that my patients barely survive and sometimes perish on, but a real hope, a robust hope, a hope nourished by true investment in our future. Thank you.

2 comments:

Ned said...

Ned's Note: I have moved the following comment by "Little Cat" from its original location under "NANDA" to here, as this is the post it deals with:

"Dear Mr. Hammar I would address you as Dr. but there-in lies my problems... I have read your blog and while I find you to be a gifted writer I find muself less believing in you as a Doctor! You see I never had medical insurance, my entire life and through the years i managed to pay cash to a few good doctors who treated me with respect, honesty. They truley cared and they did the best they possibly could for me, they understood my situation and did what they could to help me. What a different experience I have found with you. I have learned that now that I do have medical insurance I find myself being judged, disrespected and lied to my face at every turn!! And here you are on your blog... Mr oh so noble running your mouth about how very much you care!!! are you ----- serious, Ned? You spout your mouth off, supposedly to help give voice to the masses. Well being one of those masses am tired of keeping my mouth shut! Im tired of being judged and disrespeted, tired of being lied to! So how dare you? How dare you choose the most pathetic, the saddest cases from your clinic to preach about? When its your voice speaking for the masses? How dare you exploit someone else tradgedy, home life or mental conditions? Who the ----- do you think you are, my educated friend? Why not talk about the true masses like the acute patients who depend on regular care and medications to preserve what little quality of life they have or were stories like that just not heart rendering enough for you to use? The $17 dollar man? no one, not you or a collection from employees at your clinic could be bothered to offer him finacial help for a few months so he could get back to work and be able to afford his own medications? You couldnt find it in your heart to loan or give a man a few months of a lousy $17 a month medication? No, not you... You, instead choose to spend six and a half hours driving to say your piece for us masses.Useing this poor mans story to elevate yourself as you await the call telling you he succeeded in killing himself, all because of $17 lousy dollars you coulndt be bothered enough about to offer this man help yourself.Hell a add on the board at your clinic could have made enough to help this poor man. And Im quite sure that the money you spent giving voice to all us masses could have boughten that man medications for years! And yet here's your blog and you shooting your mouth off about FIRST DO NO HARM. I can quite readily assure you Mr. Hammar that you yourself have caused much HARM. Go back to writting childrens books and stories, at least there is an editor and a publisher who can make ----- sure you DO NO HARM!! Where as a Doctor answers, in reality to no one (unless its years later and too late to help the patient) allowing you to cause as much harm as you can! So CONGRATS dear Doctor you have succeeded in at least part of your blogs name... the DO HARM part!! and again my congrats on that, it must feel like quite the accoplishment I do applaud you!!!

Ned said...

Please see my response in the new posting, "The Mail" (Jan. 14th), as I seem unable to put it here.
-N.H.